Neutrogena Smokey Kohl Eyeliner with Antioxidant Vitamin E, Water-Resistant & Smooth-Gliding Eyeliner Makeup, Jet Black, 0.014 oz

This is the first kohl pencil I've tried that actually stays put on my lower lash line without smudging by noon. The jet black color is intense and really makes my eyes pop, and the fact that it's water-resistant is a huge plus for my long days.

Finally, a kohl pencil that doesn't drag or pull on my lash line—this one is impressively creamy and the jet black color is rich with just one pass. I love that it stays put through a long day but still washes off easily.

This glides on so smoothly I don’t have to tug at my eyelid, and the water-resistant formula stayed put through a tearjerker movie. The vitamin E makes it feel less drying than other eyeliners I’ve tried.