Neutrogena

The texture change from solid balm to silky oil is so satisfying, and it melts even stubborn waterproof mascara without any tugging. I use it on my face too, and it leaves my skin feeling clean and nourished instead of stripped. This two-pack is perfect for keeping one in my gym bag.

This barely takes a pea-sized amount to melt through a full face of waterproof mascara and long-wear lipstick. It rinses clean without that greasy residue some others leave behind, and my skin feels soft, not stripped. Usually a cleansing balm can sting my eyes, but this one didn't at all.

I was skeptical about a balm turning into oil, but it dissolves my waterproof mascara without any tugging or irritation. The travel size is perfect for my gym bag, and one tub lasts me over a month with daily use.

This stuff melts through even my waterproof mascara like butter, and I love that it transforms from a balm to a silky oil without leaving any greasy residue. A little scoop goes a long way, so this pack of two should last me months.

My sensitive skin usually hates cleansers, but this balm melted away a full face of waterproof mascara without any burning or stinging. It transforms into a silky oil that rinses cleanly, and the travel-friendly size is perfect for my gym bag.

I’ve been using this balm for a week and it completely dissolves my waterproof eyeliner without any greasy residue. The texture turns to oil so smoothly, and it leaves my skin feeling soft, not stripped. For the price of the two-pack, it’s a great daily staple.

Finally, a balm that melts away even my waterproof mascara without leaving that greasy film behind. The way it turns into a silky oil on my skin makes the whole process feel luxurious, and it's gentle enough for my sensitive eyes.

I usually need two passes to get all my mascara off, but one scoop of this balm dissolves everything including stubborn matte lipstick. The oil texture doesn't irritate my sensitive eyes at all.

This stuff completely melted off my waterproof mascara without any harsh scrubbing, and a tiny bit goes a long way too. My skin felt super clean but not stripped or dry afterwards. Definitely worth grabbing this two-pack for travel.

I was a little skeptical about a balm-to-oil formula, but this one dissolves even my waterproof mascara in seconds without any tugging. The vitamin E leaves my skin feeling soft afterward, not stripped. It’s perfect for throwing in my gym bag, too—the jar hasn’t leaked once.